Clever or Lazy? A Dive Into the Dancing with the Stars Cover Songs

Article by Parisa Nosrati

Photo by Eric McCandless/Disney | Getty Images

As Dancing With the Stars returns for its 35th season, so does the buzz on the newest stars. With all of the excitement from fans, along comes the curiosity over the music. Someone is always talking about why the show uses covers, and someone is always a little angry over it.

Dancing With the Stars themselves have not come out with any kind of statement or explanation, but people have begun to come to their own conclusions, the biggest one being a financial aspect. Artists often charge high fees for their songs and place restrictions. Licensing a real song can be tricky, so people think it could have something to do with that.

People also think it could be due to the modifications of their songs, and how they often don’t use the full version. So for the dances, they can edit the tempo and length easily.

All of these explanations are likely to be true, but we can go more in depth over what it actually takes to get rights to a song, and whether it would even be possible for Dancing With the Stars to do so.

Photo by Entertainment Weekly

When it comes to a song, there are two copyrighted aspects of it: the musical composition and the sound recording. One would need a synchronization license for the music composition, but this wouldn’t give access to the actual lyrics. To get that, one would need a master use license as well.

To get a synchronization license, there are multiple sources and organizations that one could refer to. However, getting a master license is more difficult, and usually comes from the record label directly. Thus, one would have to find out the record label who owns the song and contact them.

So, could Dancing With the Stars get music licensing if they wanted to? Yes, they could, and they have before for certain songs. It would require multiple steps, but it could certainly be done.

The show airs on ABC, which – along with certain other streaming platforms – has public performance licenses, allowing them to broadcast only the musical compositions. Again, they would have to contact the record label to get a master license, which could take an exorbitant amount of time and money.

Photo by ABC | Dancing with the Stars

So instead, the show uses cover versions of songs, for access to the musical composition is already provided, and don’t have to go through the process of gaining access to the actual song sung by the artist. 

Many people are split between whether this is a clever business decision, or just lazy. The show has displayed no intention of using real songs, so whether the audience likes it or not, the covers are here to stay.